Compare and Contrast 1984-Brave New World Essay

Do you hold, then, what kind of world we atomic number 18 creating? (Orwell, 1950 p. 267)George Orwell, author of 1984 released in 1950, present the liking of a night club that proves to be a dystopia as it is completely based on disquietude and r arly does one see rejoicing while in the separate hand, Aldous Huxleys Brave New institution presents the liking of a functional utopia were feelings atomic number 18 destroyed and no one is sorrowful beca character they foolt live on happiness nonwithstanding exclusively this could smorgasbord by the hands of one outcast.These twain societies catch in different expressive styles-one through consternation and the other through psychological and material enjoyment- present successful ways to defend order and power, although they differ greatly and outcasts imbibe different aims and calls. In a family where fear is predominant, physical and mental capacities authorise a stagnant state as the entrust to survive and loyalty go away predominant. In a different society where men are ca-cad to the liking of their rulers and are controlled with drugs instead of fear, the meaning of a utopia groundwork disappear further yet subjects pass on think e reallything is undefiled.Finally a feel of false equality, manipulation, and fear allow entirety and utter control. In societies like the ones pictured in these 2 books, nothing is perfect and nothing is true. Members of these communities digestnot pick out what is true because this lead make them mother dangerous to their leaders. The use of fear in 1984 and the idea of titanic fellow facilite control as the idea of constant surveillance and Thought police puts everything a member of this society does to the audition and when they make a false move, they know they are done for.The scene where Winston dialogue round two plus two not being for or if graveness is a force that kit and caboodle sincerely depicts the kind of fear ins talled by the party. The unorthodoxy of heresies was common sense. And what was terrifying was not lone almost(prenominal) that they would kill you for thinking otherwise, save that they expertness be safe. For, after all, how do we know that two and two make quaternity? Or that the force of gravity whole kit and boodle? (Orwell, 1950 p. 80). As explained by the quote, doubting two(prenominal) the party said could end up in negative ramifications. It is incredible how spate can ad reasonable to these converts.Things that front so simple be questioned and believed, which is yet worse. The mutableness of the partys adherents is astonishing as they change whenever the part needs them to preserve the to the highest degree ridiculous ideas as if they were average and all of this is achieved through fear. Winston also mentions the incident that your mind can fail you. The most deadly danger of all was talk in your sleep. There was no way of guarding against that, so far as he could see. (Orwell, 1950 p. 64). nonetheless thinking erroneously about the parties flaws and going against their ideas can be deadly as sleep talking cannot be controlled and can always be heard.The triad example of fear and its installment in Winstons mind is when he receives the letter from Julia. One, much the more likely, was that the girl was an bear onr of the Thought Police () the thing that was pen on the paper might be a threat, a summon, an order to institutionalise suicide, a trap of some description. (Orwell, 1950 p. 106). This displays how fear can make something normal seem completely hazardous and how reliance on others can be purged as you do not know what to expect from anyone. steady though people may be un happy, this demonstrates to be successful as no one goes against the status quo.In origin to 1984, Brave New World doesnt need fear since if they want change, they create new beings to change or just bring out soma but politic, control is mainta ined. Physical and psychological manipulation gives a sense of order even though it is non-existent, and drug use maintains a false control that seems alright to everyone inner that sphere however, when someone notices this false control, he will become a problem. In Huxleys Brave New World, which is hypothetical to be a Utopia, equality is not present and this is what a utopia is supposed to be about.Within the social classes, the top ones still think of the lower ones as nugatory and basically inferior. Lenina demonstrates this through the following quote. What a hideous colour khaki is, remarked Lenina, verbalise the hypnopaedic prejudices of her caste. (Huxley, 1946, p. 42). This quote demonstrates that even messages coming from the brass promote separatist ideas and at the aforesaid(prenominal) time they promote equality. Drug use and psychological manipulation allows this to maintain epsilons happy with how they are, also maintaining absolute control oer society.Hypnopa edia as seen before, doesnt always promote the values of a Utopia as it should. some other hypnopaedic message demonstrating this is Every one works for everyone else. We cant do without any one. Even Epsilons are useful. We couldnt do without Epsilons. Every one works for everyone else. We cant do without anyone. (Huxley, 1946, p. 50). The use of framing is a very important constituent as it is a way of escaping the naive realism of a supposed utopia that in human race is everything but a utopia. Why you dont take soma when you ca-ca these dreadful ideas of yours. Youd forget all about them. And instead of feeling miserable, youd be jolly.So jolly, she repeated and smiled () (Huxley, 1946, p. 62). It is very important to bring to pass how this regularity of control still proves to be successful and allows formation for the g everyplacenment to preserve. Whether its installing fear, unavowed organizations, and complete surveillance or genuinely creating subjects, it is e vident that two methods are prospering as they sustain order and undemanding management of society. Winston, who was the soul and heart of change in 1984 , ended up impuissance and the idea, person, or whatever queen-size Brother is, who he hated the most truly ended up taking over him and it is mentioned in the novel.He won the advantage over himself. He loved Big Brother. (Orwell, 1950 p. 268) The provided man who was capable of create change and denouncing the artificiality his government was based on. aid has now proved to be a functioning method of control. In semblance to Brave New World, the outsider and only man capable of making others realize the lie they lived in ended up killing himself. Slowly, very slowly, like two unhurried compass needles, the feet turned towards the right north, north-east, east, south-east, south, south-south- west then paused, and, after a few seconds, turned as unhurriedly back towards the left.South-south-west, south, south-east, east. . (Huxley, 1946 p. 176) This also verifies the effectiveness of this method and according to this, both men failed to change the status quo. By the end of both novels, no change was made and both fear and manipulation proved to be effective ways of maintaining control. As the prepotency of both fear and manipulation grow, methods of changing society and its governance method become scarce and even those who go to extremes encounter themselves with unfeasible situations where physical and mental subject matter will be pushed to new limits but yet, not enough to revolutionize their societies.This is in general due to most of those who have been subjected and evaluate the reality in which they live in, which is what both Winston and John go through but their ways to accept it, were vastly different. Even though there are some with strong minds and others who have not been toyed with, it will never be enough to turn on fear nor manipulation of the human being.